Hola fellow taco lovers! If your quest for the perfect fish taco is a never-ending adventure, have we got a treat for you. Amelia Island has a diverse array of dining spots serving up some seriously scrumptious fish tacos, each with its own unique flair. So, without further ado, let’s dive into our top seven picks, scattered from north island to south island and everywhere in between. Delicioso!

1. Cantina Louie

Crossing over onto Amelia Island, your first stop for fish tacos has to be Cantina Louie. This vibrant spot boasts a laid-back atmosphere and a menu bursting with flavor. Try their Mahi and/or Grouper Street Taco – both lightly breaded and grilled, with added peruvian sauce that’ll make your taste buds dance. All tacos are served in a flour tortilla each with special toppings that are oh so good! 960062 Gateway Blvd

2. Sandbar Amelia Island

What could be better than sinking your toes in the sand while indulging in some mouthwatering fish tacos? At Sandbar Amelia Island, you can do just that! Located right on the beach, this tasty eatery offers up Crispy Mahi or Shrimp Tacos served with mango salsa, romaine lettuce and chipotle tarter for a kick. Pair that with an ice cold beverage and you’ve got yourself the ultimate beachside dining experience! 2910 Atlantic Avenue

3. Salty Pelican

The Salty Pelican is a beloved local dining spot known for its laid-back vibe, waterfront views, and really good food. The Blackened Fish Taco and Shrimp Taco are both delicious but it’s the signature Tuna Taco that steals the show. Prepared rare, these tacos are served with cabbage, pico de gallo, seaweed salad and a cucumber wasabi sauce that will open your sinuses. But, that’s okay because they’ve got plenty of refreshing beverages to wash it down with. 12 N Front Street

4. Pepper’s Cocina Mexicana & Tequila Bar

For those craving a taste of authentic Mexican flavor, Pepper’s is the place to be. Located right on Centre Street in downtown Fernandina, this family-owned restaurant has been serving up some of the best Mexican fare for years. Their grilled Baja Fish or Shrimp Tacos are topped with cabbage, pico de gallo, avocado, and a creamy chipotle lime sauce for a true culinary delight. Be sure to try them with one of their famous margaritas for the full experience! Or, come in on Tuesdays for a taco flight! 530 Centre Street

5. Timoti’s Seafood Shak

A local favorite tucked away on a downtown side street, Timoti’s is renowned for its commitment to sustainability and sourcing the freshest seafood available. Their fish tacos are no exception, featuring lean and flaky Mahi served blackened or grilled with slaw and a drizzle of signature sauce. The shrimp and tuna tacos are just as delicious, all loaded with flavor and texture. Kids will love the outdoor pirate ship play area, too! 21 N 3rd Street

6. Coquina

Coquina, located oceanfront at The Ritz-Carlton, Amelia Island serves perhaps the most delicious Blackened Fish Tacos of your life. What makes these blackened fish tacos so good, you ask? It’s the Ensenada Slaw and Pico de Gallo they are topped with. Ensenada slaw is a lightly dressed, crisp vegetable salad with a touch of heat from hot sauce and a touch of acidity from lime juice. It’s next level good. Have a glass of wine and take in the stunning ocean views. This is island life! 4750 Amelia Island Pkwy

7. The Surf Restaurant & Bar

The Surf has been making folks fat and happy since 1957. It’s a Fernandina Beach staple with a deliciously eclectic menu. If you’re looking for light fare or a full course meal all while catching the sea breeze off the ocean, this is the place for you. Try the Crispy Shrimp Taco or Blackened Mahi Taco served with cabbage slaw, roasted corn salsa, and a remoulade sauce.  “Life is Good” at The Surf. 3199 S Fletcher Avenue

There you have it, folks – seven incredible spots to get your fish (or seafood) taco fix right here on Amelia Island. I hope you’re hungry.