Seafood is a big deal here. Shrimpers and fishermen have been feeding folks on and around Amelia Island with bounties from the sea for years. It’s literally in our blood, sweat, and tears so it’s no wonder that we boast some of the best seafood spots around.

Whether you’re craving a casual fish taco, local fried shrimp, or a fine dining experience, there is something to satisfy every “sea”foodie’s palate. Here are 10 restaurants to get your seafood fix:

1. Timoti’s Seafood Shak

Located in the heart of Fernandina Beach, Timoti’s Seafood Shak is a local favorite known for its laid-back atmosphere and incredible seafood. Their fish tacos, shrimp baskets, and tuna poke bowls are all crowd-pleasers. With a menu that focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, Timoti’s offers a delicious, no-frills seafood experience that the whole family will love. Kids will especially love the outdoor pirate ship to play on!

2. Salty Pelican Bar & Grill

For those who love their seafood with a side of waterfront views, Salty Pelican Bar & Grill is the place to be. Situated right on the Amelia River, this spot serves up hearty portions of tuna nachos, oysters on the half shell, and delicious fried shrimp all with a view that’s hard to beat. Their “Seafood Pot Pie” made with shrimp, scallops, crab meat, sweet potato, and bacon is a must-try, offering a tasty seafood sampling in one satisfying dish.

3. Down Under Restaurant

A beloved hidden gem, Down Under Restaurant is where you’ll find a fusion of seafood and Southern comfort food. The relaxed, unpretentious setting “down under” the bridge makes it a perfect spot for a casual meal, sunset watching, and live music on the deck. Don’t miss their entrees like “Oysters Rockefeller”, “Crab Cakes”, “Spicy Fried Local Shrimp”, or their signature Grouper Monterey”.

4. The Boat House

Located in downtown Fernandina Beach, The Boat House is a popular dining establishment boasting a diverse and flavorful menu. The fried calamari appetizer is a true treat for the taste buds providing a flavor explosion that will leave you craving more – like “Cedar Teriyaki Salmon” served with Asian vegetables, lo mein, soy, and ginger. Sit inside or outside on the deck with nightly entertainment. 

5. The Crab Trap

Located in downtown Fernandina Beach, The Crab Trap has been serving up tasty fare from the sea since 1979! It’s safe to say they know a thing or two about how to prepare seafood. And, much like their name implies, this is the place to satisfy any seafood craving but if crab is your weakness, this is your spot. King crab, snow crab, deviled crab, crab cake sandwiches. It’s all good.

6. Salt Life Food Shack

Salt Life Food Shack is all about casual, laid-back dining with a focus on fun and flavorful dishes of all kinds. Their menu features everything from fish tacos to shrimp and grits, all served in a vibrant, beachy setting. Start with the “Smoked Grouper Dip” and finish with the “Fried Captains Platter”, offering a bit of everything for those who want to sample a variety of dishes. Dine inside, outside on the deck, or upstairs overlooking the ocean.

7. Sliders Seaside Grill

At Sliders Seaside Grill, the menu is as diverse as the ocean views. Kids will love the crispy chicken tenders, popcorn fried shrimp, and creamy gouda mac & cheese. For the grown-ups, there’s a bounty of fresh seafood that’ll make your taste buds dance. Think shrimp & grits, crab-topped flounder, oysters on the half shell, and bangin’ shrimp tacos. The laid-back vibe and outdoor tiki bar make it a perfect place for a relaxed meal after a day at the beach.

8. Shucker’s

If you’re a fan of oysters, look no further than Shucker’s Oyster Bar & Grill, known for its fresh oysters and beautiful views of the intracoastal waterway surrounding Amelia Island. In addition to oysters, Shucker’s serves up a range of other seafood dishes, including a catch of the day served grilled, fried or blackened; and their famous “Shrimp & Grits” offering a spicy taste of the south. The outdoor deck is ideal for live music, sunset watching, and cocktail sipping.

9. Sandbar Amelia Island

Located right on the beach, Sandbar Amelia Island offers stunning ocean views and a relaxed atmosphere. Their menu features a mix of seafood classics and innovative dishes, including “Crispy Mahi or Shrimp Tacos”, and “Blackened Redfish”, as well as sweet & spicy shrimp served with ranch dressing. Dine indoors, on the patio, or at picnic tables with your toes in the sand.

10. The Surf Restaurant

The Surf Restaurant & Bar has served residents and guests of Amelia Island since 1957 and gives off the summer, small-town beach vibes that folks have come to love. With a combination of ocean breezes, and nightly entertainment, dining at The Surf is a win-win for all. Think fried calamari, “Lobster Bisque”, or a “Shrimp Platter” cooked any way you want them. Life is good at The Surf!

Pack your bags and your appetite and set sail on a seafood adventure to Amelia Island that will leave you hooked!